German pastor: Anti-Israel film boosts Nazi support
A German regional court in the state of Bavaria covering
the cities of Nürnberg-Fürth ruled on Friday that a pastor will continue to be
able to describe a film about the Israel-Palestinian conflict as anti-Semitic.
The pastor argued the film contributes to strengthening
the neo-Nazi scene and anti-Semitism in the federal republic, according to a
report in the local Nordbayern newspaper.
The Nordbayern reported that the court affirmed that the
pastor's criticism is protected by freedom of speech. The pastor accused the
film by Stefanie Landgraf of anti-Semitism because of comparisons between the Jewish
state an Nazi Germany. The film is titled, “We refuse to be enemies.”
It compares a Palestinian refugee camp in the West Bank
with the Warsaw Ghetto during the Holocaust. In addition to the alleged
demonization of Israel through the Nazi comparison, the pastor labeled the film
anti-Semitic because in the film, a Jewish museum is charged with manipulating
the Holocaust in order to steal land from the Palestinians.
Nathan Gelbart, a leading international expert on media
law, wrote the Jerusalem Post by email,"The magistrate court has not ruled
Ms. Landgraf´s movie as anti-Semitic but just has allowed the defendant to
continue to call this movie anti-Semitic as a legitimate expression of his
views and thoughts which are protected by Article 5 of the German
Constitution."
Gelbart , who practices law for the Berlin-based FPS
firm, added "Ms. Landgraf might not like it but has to live with it since
the defendant has not crossed the red line calling her movie anti-semitic
without any reasons." The film spat comes on the heels of a heated debate
over modern anti-Semtism. The Spiegel columnist Jakob Augstein compared the
Gaza Strip to a camp in connection with Israel's policies toward the
Hamas-controlled enclave. The German word for camp evokes a concentration camp
from the Nazi period.
German critics of Augstein pointed to the EU’s definition
of contemporary anti-Semitism, which outlines parallels between Israel and Nazi
Germany to be a crystal clear example of anti-Semitism.
The head of the city’s school administrator in Nürnberg,
Klemens Gsell, from the Christian Social Union party, barred the Nürnberger
school system from showing the film. Landgraf told Nürnberger Nachrichten daily
on Monday that “Germany must stop to impose such restrictions." He said Israel
is responsible for the expulsion of the Palestinians and permanently violates
human rights.
At a film presentation on Sunday in Nürnberg, an elderly
lady said “We have paid for what our parents did" and “today we do not
have to put on a muzzle.” According to the article, many spectators from the
audience totaling 180 applauded her remarks.
The oldest serving head of a German Jewish community,
Arno Hamburger, Israelitischen Kultusgemeinde (IKG) in Nürnberg also slammed
the film for its distorted depiction of Israel
Comments
Post a Comment