Israel - In the Knesset, English is verboten
Many Israelis learned after the recent elections that in
order to serve in the Knesset, a politician must give up any additional
citizenship he or she might have beside the Israeli one. But what isn’t common
knowledge is that foreign-born Israeli lawmakers also have to abandon their
mother tongues.
On Wednesday, at a Knesset session dedicated to Jonathan
Pollard, the spy serving a life sentence in an American prison, MK Dov Lipman
(Yesh Atid) wanted to personally plead with US President Barack Obama, who is
arriving in Israel later this month, to pardon Pollard. To better reach the
president’s heart, Lipman planned to address him in English, straight from the
Knesset lectern.
“However, I learned that this is prohibited according to
the Knesset bylaws and, therefore, I will address President Obama in Hebrew,”
he said during his speech, held entirely in (grammatically flawless, but
heavily accented) Hebrew. Lipman, who immigrated to Israel seven years ago and
this year became the first US-born MK since 1984, then implored the president
to “act with the American values of compassion and tolerance and free Jonathan.”
Is English really verboten in the Knesset? The
parliament’s spokesperson had yet to reply to a Times of Israel query at the
time of publication. But the new “Knesset Rules of Procedure,” which were
approved on May 30, 2012, do not mention any such rule, at least not
explicitly. Chapter 6 of section C – Business of the Knesset, paragraph 41(d)
states (translated, ironically, into English): “A Member of the Knesset shall
speak in the Knesset plenum in an appropriate manner, using acceptable language,
and in a manner that preserves the dignity of the Knesset, and shall not
perform in the plenum an act involving a slight to the dignity of the Knesset,
the dignity of one of its members, or the proceedings of its debates.”
Apparently English is not considered an “acceptable
language” for Israeli lawmakers. Luckily for foreign dignitaries, however, the
Knesset speaker has the right, with the approval of the House Committee, to
invite a head of state, a prime minister, a head of a foreign parliament or a head
of an international organization in which Israel is a member to address
Israel’s parliament — “and they shall be entitled to speak in their own
language,” according to chapter 1, paragraph 22.
Indeed, many world leaders have spoke to the Israeli
people from the Knesset podium in languages other than Hebrew, most notably
Egyptian president Anwar Sadat, who on November 20, 1977, addressed the plenum
in Arabic.
When in 2008 German Chancellor Angela Merkel gave a
speech in her native tongue, a handful of MKs boycotted the event. “It is very,
very difficult to hear German in the Knesset,” former tourism minister Yitzhak
Levy (National Religious Party) said at the time.
Obama, meanwhile, decided to forgo the opportunity to
address the Israeli people in the Knesset. Instead, he chose a politically
neutral hall in Jerusalem.
Comments
Post a Comment